If that's the case, is there an alternative way to accomplish our goal in the product? Thanks!

I think we use workboards extensively, but this is the only company I've used Phab so I don't have a diverse sample set. We have workboards for subprojects, workboards for parent projects to view a team's list of new requests and high-level sprint plans (e.g. a backlog column, and a column for each sprint milestone). We click through on the milestone columns to view a sprint-specific workboard (typical Kanban columns).

In fact, I'm pretty surprised that your workflow doesn't hit major bugs/issues all the time, unless this stuff is currently far bugger than I believe it is. If you ever tag "Project Y" before moving a task to "Milestone 3", you'd no longer be able to move it from the workboard since it would vanish (until T11036)? Do you have a very specific sequence of organizational steps you take to avoid these issues? Are you just not using workboards at all?

(And, unless it's also bugged, I believe moving from a milestone to a non-milestone column on "Project X" should already strip subprojects. The proposed behavior just prevents there from being any subprojects to strip.)

I agree, I don't think project tags should ever be automatically removed.

Is there a syntax to close audits? Something like "Fixes: <commit-hash>"?

I intend that it can not be in "Project X > Milestone 3" and "Project X > Project Y" simultaneously. Note that the parent projects are the same (both "X").

No, I don't mean that, as written.

Regarding the expected behavior, do you mean it should not be possible for a task to be in both a milestone and subproject simultaneously?

This has been out in the world for a little bit without exploding. I'd like to maybe do a bit of UI touchup but that can happen after T12272.

I actually also think this is a big improvement. When you search on the web there are not many browser based open source mind map tools. I use XMind, but it requires a desktop application. We now started to use Phabricator Pholio (pretty cool) for our mockups. And internal Wiki pages to document our plans and include the Phababricator tasks. Mind maps are very fast and useful for brainstorm sessions. It would be very cool if that also can be attached as a related object to a task. I wish I could help you guys to develop it, but I can't. And I understand that building that type of add-on is a lot of work. I understand that this can't be done in a few weeks, or even months. Just wanted to share that I think this is a nice add-on that will make Phabricator an even better tool then JIRA for example. Keep up the good work, guys :-)

If you believe you've found a bug in Phabricator, we need all the information discussed in Contributing Bug Reports to move forward. Specifically:

I believe the expected behavior is that "milestone, subproject" kicks the task out of the milestone (leaving it in only the subproject) while "subproject, milestone" kicks it out of the subproject (leaving it in only the milestone).

I'm going to close this because I think it no longer meets the modern requirements for a feature request (it was filed in 2012). In particular, I don't understand why this is a problem:

The workflow thing is somewhat nontrivial. Previously, we would explicitly downgrade "Accept" into "Accepted Older" when an author used "Request Review".

From D17564, there's a minor workflow issue with "request review" incorrectly putting accepted changes back into an "accepted" state from this.

I've updated {D17564} to address the tokenization and word stemming issues.

Yep, thanks!

It's possible T10872 is also related/is a duplicate.

Phabricator is Awesome!
Thanks again.

It works that way too.

It works! Nice! Thanks @chad!
It can be a bit more elegant to create the panel without saving the query fist, but doesn't matter. :)

Build your query and save it first.

Thanks @chad for your answer!
That looks almost what I wanted. The small issue is that I can't past my custom query. There are only a few options.

We encountered a weird bug: a colleague was shown as Busy today because she's attending an event that takes place tomorrow. Calendar on her profile page:

is srs bsness mode taking over? i'm in a panic :[

THANKS FOR RUINING THE JOKE EVERYONE

Probably resolved?

I can't reproduce this any more.

high priority!

I don't see anything here worth moving forward. I don't think the bar needs to cover more advanced topics and more advanced users should be OK with reading documentation.

We need reproduction steps to move forward. See Providing Reproduction Steps.

so it's tokenizing maniphest.query as two separate tokens

Would be happy to see this feature. My company use different team names as columns of the work board. When a task is reassigned from a dev to a tester, I need to manually move it from Dev column to QA column.
With this feature implemented, I would be able to configure a rule that when a task is assigned to a specific person, the task will be automatically moved to a column, say the Dev column for example.

Maniphest advanced search is somewhat buried, indeed. I think one easy solution to this would be to add "Task search" to the main phab menu (using the new custom menus feature)... In fact, I think I will do that now at https://phabricator.wikimedia.org