Feature RequestExperimental
ActivePublic

Properties

Description

This task was filed through the "New Feature Request" form.

Recent Activity

Today

chad added a comment to T12627: Update Fund for Modular Transactions.

I have a rough cut of this one.

Sun, Apr 23, 4:13 AM · Prioritized, Restricted Project, Mail, User Preferences, Owners, Feature Request
chad created T12627: Update Fund for Modular Transactions.
Sun, Apr 23, 4:13 AM · Prioritized, Restricted Project, Mail, User Preferences, Owners, Feature Request
chad created T12626: Update Pholio for Modular Transactions.
Sun, Apr 23, 4:13 AM · Prioritized, Restricted Project, Mail, User Preferences, Owners, Feature Request
chad created T12625: Update Phriction for Modular Transactions.
Sun, Apr 23, 4:13 AM · Prioritized, Restricted Project, Mail, User Preferences, Owners, Feature Request
chad created T12624: Update Ponder for Modular Transactions.
Sun, Apr 23, 4:12 AM · Prioritized, Restricted Project, Mail, User Preferences, Owners, Feature Request
chad created T12623: Update Slowvote for Modular Transactions.
Sun, Apr 23, 4:12 AM · Prioritized, Restricted Project, Mail, User Preferences, Owners, Feature Request

Yesterday

chad added a comment to T12620: Add link to external bug tracker feature in Differential.

Please use Conphernce or Ponder if you have questions about Phabricator.

Sat, Apr 22, 1:29 PM · Diffusion, Differential, Feature Request
chad closed T12620: Add link to external bug tracker feature in Differential as "Invalid".
Sat, Apr 22, 1:27 PM · Diffusion, Differential, Feature Request
mirage315 created T12620: Add link to external bug tracker feature in Differential.
Sat, Apr 22, 10:22 AM · Diffusion, Differential, Feature Request

Fri, Apr 21

sgrimm added a comment to T12410: Cycle Time and Lead Time Reports.

It would be useful to extend this concept to the lifecycles of other Phabricator objects, not just Maniphest tasks. For example, people on my team have sometimes wanted to see a histogram of how long it takes Differential diffs to get reviewed, especially if we can break it down by author and/or reviewer.

Fri, Apr 21, 11:01 PM · Feature Request
amckinley added a revision to T11476: Record transaction histories when users edit application capabilities: D17757: Implement modular transactions for application policy changes.
Fri, Apr 21, 7:46 PM · Contributor Onboarding, Restricted Project, Applications, Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12618: Create a revision/diff using Conduit which sets the base revision.

Oh, you're right. I misread an implication of implementation specifics into "set", but the actual language doesn't actually suggest an implementation.

Fri, Apr 21, 6:50 PM · Mercurial, Differential, Conduit, Feature Request
cspeckmim added a comment to T12618: Create a revision/diff using Conduit which sets the base revision.

I tried to not specifically ask for a change to API or parsing, just that the missing bit I need is a base revision set on the new diff.

Fri, Apr 21, 6:40 PM · Mercurial, Differential, Conduit, Feature Request
epriestley added a project to T12618: Create a revision/diff using Conduit which sets the base revision: Mercurial.
Fri, Apr 21, 5:39 PM · Mercurial, Differential, Conduit, Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12618: Create a revision/diff using Conduit which sets the base revision.

A maybe-less-complicated approach here could be:

Fri, Apr 21, 5:38 PM · Mercurial, Differential, Conduit, Feature Request
ftdysa added a comment to T12617: Composer packages.json generator.

@nervus70, I use satis to do this and it works fine with phabricator. You should easy be able to use https://secure.phabricator.com/api/diffusion.repository.search to generate the satis config if you have a ton of repos.

Fri, Apr 21, 5:27 PM · Feature Request
cspeckmim created T12618: Create a revision/diff using Conduit which sets the base revision.
Fri, Apr 21, 5:27 PM · Mercurial, Differential, Conduit, Feature Request
epriestley closed T12617: Composer packages.json generator as "Wontfix".

This isn't a good fit for the upstream.

Fri, Apr 21, 5:20 PM · Feature Request
nervus70 created T12617: Composer packages.json generator.
Fri, Apr 21, 5:06 PM · Feature Request
benwick added a comment to T12615: Make Phriction ToC more structured.

You may be right, that the root problem is people putting to much content in Phriction articles. But even a need content seperation like this one

Fri, Apr 21, 4:51 PM · Feature Request
chad added a comment to T12615: Make Phriction ToC more structured.

The ToC is a currently a bandaid to a design problem, that people put too much information into a single page due to lack of alternative choices. Our solution moving forward isn't to just improve the ToC, but to improve Phriction overall and allow more CMS level customization (like a permanent sidenav). Knowing why so much information is placed on a page is the root problem we're looking for. If we just improve the ToC, I don't feel we're solved the root problem.

Fri, Apr 21, 4:36 PM · Feature Request
chad added a comment to T12615: Make Phriction ToC more structured.

We don't consider that to a be a root problem.

Fri, Apr 21, 4:23 PM · Feature Request
benwick added a comment to T12615: Make Phriction ToC more structured.

The root problem is clear: The ToC is useless in a highly hierarchical Phriction article with many nested headers.

Fri, Apr 21, 4:21 PM · Feature Request
benwick added a comment to T12615: Make Phriction ToC more structured.

It does include this direction (T9868), so I'm looking forward to this.

Fri, Apr 21, 4:09 PM · Feature Request
chad merged task T12615: Make Phriction ToC more structured into T9379: Build Phriction v3.
Fri, Apr 21, 2:17 PM · Feature Request
chad added a comment to T12615: Make Phriction ToC more structured.

We already have a path forward on the next iteration of Phriction, and it doesn't include this direction. Please read Contributing Feature Requests and Describing Root Problems if you have future feature suggestions, root problems are required for any request filed. Thanks!

Fri, Apr 21, 2:17 PM · Feature Request
epriestley moved T10954: Differential keyboard shortcut inline selection reticle is visually unclear (bad z-index?) from Backlog to Glitches on the Inline Comments board.
Fri, Apr 21, 12:23 PM · Inline Comments, Differential, Feature Request
epriestley moved T11401: Add ability to quote, edit, view raw, view history, and remove inline comments from Backlog to Future on the Inline Comments board.
Fri, Apr 21, 12:22 PM · Inline Comments, Restricted Project, Differential, Feature Request
epriestley added a project to T10954: Differential keyboard shortcut inline selection reticle is visually unclear (bad z-index?): Inline Comments.
Fri, Apr 21, 12:20 PM · Inline Comments, Differential, Feature Request
epriestley added a project to T11401: Add ability to quote, edit, view raw, view history, and remove inline comments: Inline Comments.
Fri, Apr 21, 12:20 PM · Inline Comments, Restricted Project, Differential, Feature Request
epriestley merged T6273: Inline comments do not support editing (Pholio, Differential, Diffusion) into T11401: Add ability to quote, edit, view raw, view history, and remove inline comments.
Fri, Apr 21, 12:04 PM · Inline Comments, Restricted Project, Differential, Feature Request
epriestley closed T10607: Remote target/landing branch in Diff details as "Resolved".

My expectation is that the workflow in the task description will generally show this:

Fri, Apr 21, 11:41 AM · Restricted Project, Differential, Feature Request
epriestley merged T7470: show the base branch name in Differential revision info into T10607: Remote target/landing branch in Diff details.
Fri, Apr 21, 11:26 AM · Restricted Project, Differential, Feature Request
benwick edited the description of T12615: Make Phriction ToC more structured.
Fri, Apr 21, 9:16 AM · Feature Request
benwick created T12615: Make Phriction ToC more structured.
Fri, Apr 21, 9:15 AM · Feature Request

Thu, Apr 20

epriestley closed T12609: Prevent arc land when unit tests or build fails as "Resolved".

Cool. Harbormaster integration will also give you other UI hints like these, to help communicate build status to reviewers so they don't accept a change which has failed or in-progress builds:

Thu, Apr 20, 10:46 PM · Feature Request
jessjohnson added a comment to T12609: Prevent arc land when unit tests or build fails.

Yes, it would. We haven't fully integrated the build system with Phabricator, but I'll review the docs and see how much more work we need to do.

Thu, Apr 20, 10:25 PM · Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12609: Prevent arc land when unit tests or build fails.

If you integrate with Harbormaster, users will be prompted explicitly when they try to arc land a revision with build failures:

Thu, Apr 20, 10:22 PM · Feature Request
jessjohnson added a comment to T12609: Prevent arc land when unit tests or build fails.

Engineers are not hitting a prompt when landing, they are disregarding the unit test failure message or not reviewing why the build failed. Since the build failure is on an external system, the engineer needs to view this information separately (the system posts a comment why the build failed). The overall goal of a herald rule blocking the land is so that owner can communicate that checking in code without running or successful unit tests is not cool.

Thu, Apr 20, 10:17 PM · Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12609: Prevent arc land when unit tests or build fails.

Can you provide some more context about why engineers are hitting the "builds failed" prompt, and continuing through it anyway with failing tests and/or nonbuilding code?

Thu, Apr 20, 9:02 PM · Feature Request
jessjohnson created T12609: Prevent arc land when unit tests or build fails.
Thu, Apr 20, 8:35 PM · Feature Request
kislinsk added a comment to T12374: Saved Workboard Queries.

I'm going to merge this into T12374.

If you have time, answering the questions in T12374#214870 on that task might be helpful. There are many possible implementations of this feature (e.g., per user/per workboard/global) and it's not clear to me which are desired from the use cases. It would also be helpful to understand what the major stumbling blocks are for using "bookmarks" and "saving queries to the menu" as workarounds (just cumbersome? Not the right scope/audience?).

Thu, Apr 20, 7:48 AM · Workboards, Feature Request
wjiang added a comment to T12601: Set default arguments of `ArcanistWorkflow`.

The only behavior of --lintall is to make warnings act like errors. Just raise everything at error severity to achieve the same thing without patching anything.

Thu, Apr 20, 1:29 AM · Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12601: Set default arguments of `ArcanistWorkflow`.

The only behavior of --lintall is to make warnings act like errors. Just raise everything at error severity to achieve the same thing without patching anything.

Thu, Apr 20, 1:15 AM · Feature Request
wjiang added a comment to T12601: Set default arguments of `ArcanistWorkflow`.

You are probably raising messages at "warning" severity, but want to raise them at "error" severity. See, e.g., here for a description:

T4287#47494

Thu, Apr 20, 1:13 AM · Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12601: Set default arguments of `ArcanistWorkflow`.

You are probably raising messages at "warning" severity, but want to raise them at "error" severity. See, e.g., here for a description:

Thu, Apr 20, 1:02 AM · Feature Request
wjiang added a revision to T12601: Set default arguments of `ArcanistWorkflow`: D17743: Add `setArgument` to `ArcanistWorkflow`.
Thu, Apr 20, 1:01 AM · Feature Request
wjiang updated subscribers of T12601: Set default arguments of `ArcanistWorkflow`.
Thu, Apr 20, 12:57 AM · Feature Request
wjiang created T12601: Set default arguments of `ArcanistWorkflow`.
Thu, Apr 20, 12:57 AM · Feature Request

Wed, Apr 19

epriestley added a commit to T11476: Record transaction histories when users edit application capabilities: rP95dd9dbf437a: Make Applications extend LiskDAO.
Wed, Apr 19, 11:06 PM · Contributor Onboarding, Restricted Project, Applications, Feature Request