Feature RequestExperimental
ActivePublic

Details

Description

This task was filed through the "New Feature Request" form.

Recent Activity

Yesterday

epriestley added a comment to T12842: Some improvements to Mercurial, Arcanist, and Dependent Revisions.

For (1), it's currently expected, yes. We don't create branches for dependencies in Git either, currently. I don't think this is terribly unreasonable, but I'm also not sure it's terribly useful (does it just help you keep track of which commits are part of the leaf?) and it makes cleanup more difficult by creating more total branch/bookmark artifacts in the local working copy.

Fri, Jun 23, 11:39 PM · Arcanist, Mercurial, Feature Request
cspeckmim added a comment to T12842: Some improvements to Mercurial, Arcanist, and Dependent Revisions.

For (1), it is expected to not apply bookmarks to dependency changesets that are applied as part of the patch issued? When patched one-by-one they would each obtain their bookmark.

Fri, Jun 23, 11:29 PM · Arcanist, Mercurial, Feature Request
mcorteel added a comment to T12865: Strikethrough for icons in checked remarkup list items.

Sorry, I should have led with a screenshot! I'm the biggest nitpicker, I know.

Fri, Jun 23, 5:48 PM · Remarkup, Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12842: Some improvements to Mercurial, Arcanist, and Dependent Revisions.

Some of the (3), (2), (1) stuff is that we're trying to pick a single behavior which addresses most use cases reasonably well. For example, if we use "natural" bookmark names that will tend to make things much worse for users in bucket (3).

Fri, Jun 23, 4:48 PM · Arcanist, Mercurial, Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12865: Strikethrough for icons in checked remarkup list items.

Thanks, that's much more clear than the original description!

Fri, Jun 23, 4:42 PM · Remarkup, Feature Request
mcorteel added a comment to T12865: Strikethrough for icons in checked remarkup list items.

No they're not. I know it's a tiny difference, but look at this closely (left is my proposal, right is the current state):

Fri, Jun 23, 4:41 PM · Remarkup, Feature Request
epriestley triaged T12866: Batch repository editing or repository groups for shared access control settings as Low priority.
Fri, Jun 23, 4:18 PM · Diffusion, Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12865: Strikethrough for icons in checked remarkup list items.

I'm confused here -- the icons are already struck in every browser on my system (Safari, Firefox, Chrome):

Fri, Jun 23, 4:18 PM · Remarkup, Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12866: Batch repository editing or repository groups for shared access control settings.

See also T10005 (bulk editors for all applications) and T6722.

Fri, Jun 23, 1:38 PM · Diffusion, Feature Request
chad merged task T12868: Highlight and link URI's in review titles into T3278: ⛄ Build a summary mode Remarkup engine for constrained text areas.
Fri, Jun 23, 6:29 AM · Diffusion, Differential, Feature Request
jcarrillo7 created T12868: Highlight and link URI's in review titles.
Fri, Jun 23, 6:25 AM · Diffusion, Differential, Feature Request

Thu, Jun 22

avivey added a parent task for T12866: Batch repository editing or repository groups for shared access control settings: T9287: Working with many repositories.
Thu, Jun 22, 7:26 PM · Diffusion, Feature Request
chad updated the task description for T12865: Strikethrough for icons in checked remarkup list items.
Thu, Jun 22, 7:25 PM · Remarkup, Feature Request
jcarrillo7 updated the task description for T12866: Batch repository editing or repository groups for shared access control settings.
Thu, Jun 22, 7:20 PM · Diffusion, Feature Request
jcarrillo7 added a project to T12866: Batch repository editing or repository groups for shared access control settings: Diffusion.
Thu, Jun 22, 7:19 PM · Diffusion, Feature Request
jcarrillo7 created T12866: Batch repository editing or repository groups for shared access control settings.
Thu, Jun 22, 7:19 PM · Diffusion, Feature Request
1 added a comment to T12865: Strikethrough for icons in checked remarkup list items.
Thu, Jun 22, 6:11 PM · Remarkup, Feature Request
mcorteel created T12865: Strikethrough for icons in checked remarkup list items.
Thu, Jun 22, 8:24 AM · Remarkup, Feature Request

Wed, Jun 21

chad added a comment to T12861: How to intergrate Infer's analysis result into Phabricator?.

Just to clarify, Phacility is the paid hosted version of Phabricator. If you installed Phabricator locally, we cannot help you with this request via Phacility. You'll need to follow Support Resources for your self-hosted installation.

Wed, Jun 21, 6:35 PM · Phacility, Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12861: How to intergrate Infer's analysis result into Phabricator?.

Great! Please mail support at support@phacility.com and identify which instance you're paying us for, then we're happy to help you. We won't help you here, since this isn't the right way for customers to get support.

Wed, Jun 21, 6:27 PM · Phacility, Feature Request
sencho added a comment to T12861: How to intergrate Infer's analysis result into Phabricator?.

Yes,we are Phacility customer And I deployed it on a Ubuntu server,Thank you.

Wed, Jun 21, 5:42 PM · Phacility, Feature Request
epriestley merged T12862: Diffusion: change to a flat project structure view into T10767: fold empty directories in Browse view.
Wed, Jun 21, 5:23 PM · Restricted Project, Diffusion, Feature Request
epriestley merged task T12862: Diffusion: change to a flat project structure view into T10767: fold empty directories in Browse view.
Wed, Jun 21, 5:23 PM · Diffusion, Feature Request
epriestley closed T12861: How to intergrate Infer's analysis result into Phabricator? as Invalid.

If you're a Phacility customer, please mail support at support@phacility.com (and identify your instance).

Wed, Jun 21, 5:22 PM · Phacility, Feature Request
bhchandra added a project to T12862: Diffusion: change to a flat project structure view: Diffusion.
Wed, Jun 21, 5:18 PM · Diffusion, Feature Request
sencho added a project to T12861: How to intergrate Infer's analysis result into Phabricator?: Phacility.
Wed, Jun 21, 5:17 PM · Phacility, Feature Request
bhchandra created T12862: Diffusion: change to a flat project structure view.
Wed, Jun 21, 5:17 PM · Diffusion, Feature Request
sencho created T12861: How to intergrate Infer's analysis result into Phabricator?.
Wed, Jun 21, 5:15 PM · Phacility, Feature Request

Mon, Jun 19

vanto- added a comment to T12852: just test.

haha

Mon, Jun 19, 7:38 AM
vanto- created T12852: just test.
Mon, Jun 19, 7:37 AM

Sun, Jun 18

kszatan added a comment to T12813: Integrate Harbormaster with GoCD.

I was going to wait with updating this task until I'm finished but I'm stuck on GoCD side for some time. The extension for Phabricator is 99% ready so anyone interested may give it a try:
https://github.com/kszatan/harbormaster-gocd-buildstep
It's enough to be able to schedule a pipeline in GoCD but nothing more. This issue hampers my progress with notifying Harbormaster about pipeline status. I'll update this task when all is working as planned.

Sun, Jun 18, 9:00 PM · Harbormaster, Feature Request
waxmigs2902 added a comment to T10605: Implement setOriginalText() and setReplacementText() in RuboCop driver.

done! cheers

Sun, Jun 18, 11:38 AM · Lint, Feature Request

Fri, Jun 16

charlax added a comment to T12843: Add support for creating workboard columns from the Conduit API.

Milestones works great for this, but you still have to manually create the workboard (just going into workboard and clicking create - milestones show up).

Fri, Jun 16, 1:59 PM · Conduit, Projects, Workboards, Feature Request

Wed, Jun 14

jboning updated subscribers of T11664: Add option to allow owner packages to be added as reviewers to diffs, when the diff author is in the owner package.

I'm not totally sure about how/why users are expecting the behavior in the third case.

Wed, Jun 14, 10:13 PM · Restricted Project, Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T11664: Add option to allow owner packages to be added as reviewers to diffs, when the diff author is in the owner package.

I'm not particularly strongly opposed to adding more options here, I just want to avoid the dropdown becoming this:

Wed, Jun 14, 10:08 PM · Restricted Project, Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T11664: Add option to allow owner packages to be added as reviewers to diffs, when the diff author is in the owner package.

For the compliance case, you should already be able to trigger this stronger rule ("always add the package as a reviewer, even if an owner authored it") with Herald, by writing this rule:

Wed, Jun 14, 9:58 PM · Restricted Project, Feature Request
neilfitz added a comment to T11664: Add option to allow owner packages to be added as reviewers to diffs, when the diff author is in the owner package.

As more of a point of philosophy of code review also, I (and, I think, my teammates) would say that diffs should be reviewed by someone who both:

  1. Understands the relevant code
  2. Did not write the code themselves

In other words, the combination of expertise + different perspective is of value beyond each component individually. If you believe that, then B or C should review A's diff in this case.

Wed, Jun 14, 9:56 PM · Restricted Project, Feature Request
jboning added a comment to T11664: Add option to allow owner packages to be added as reviewers to diffs, when the diff author is in the owner package.

When you put it that way, it does seem backwards.

Wed, Jun 14, 9:31 PM · Restricted Project, Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T11664: Add option to allow owner packages to be added as reviewers to diffs, when the diff author is in the owner package.

The use case in this task's description does not make sense to me.

Wed, Jun 14, 7:28 PM · Restricted Project, Feature Request
jboning added a project to T11664: Add option to allow owner packages to be added as reviewers to diffs, when the diff author is in the owner package: Restricted Project.

We're interested in this option, since we find that users are often surprised by the existing behaviour. I think this would make sense as a per-package setting, rather than a global one.

Wed, Jun 14, 5:57 PM · Restricted Project, Feature Request
20after4 added a comment to T12314: Support formal task subtypes (like "bug" vs "feature").

It would be really nice to default newly added fields to hidden. Going through 20+ forms to hide the fields is tedious.

Wed, Jun 14, 3:06 PM · EditEngine, Maniphest, Custom Fields, Feature Request
epriestley added a comment to T12843: Add support for creating workboard columns from the Conduit API.

We do something similar ourselves for technical interviews, but I just related all the tasks by embedding them in the description of a central task:

Wed, Jun 14, 12:15 PM · Conduit, Projects, Workboards, Feature Request
epriestley added a project to T12843: Add support for creating workboard columns from the Conduit API: Conduit.
Wed, Jun 14, 12:08 PM · Conduit, Projects, Workboards, Feature Request
epriestley added projects to T12843: Add support for creating workboard columns from the Conduit API: Workboards, Projects.

I think this use case is a reasonable one.

Wed, Jun 14, 12:08 PM · Conduit, Projects, Workboards, Feature Request
charlax added a comment to T12843: Add support for creating workboard columns from the Conduit API.

Just discovered I could use the Milestones feature to do that. Will try this out.

Wed, Jun 14, 9:51 AM · Conduit, Projects, Workboards, Feature Request
charlax created T12843: Add support for creating workboard columns from the Conduit API.
Wed, Jun 14, 9:45 AM · Conduit, Projects, Workboards, Feature Request
cspeckmim created T12842: Some improvements to Mercurial, Arcanist, and Dependent Revisions.
Wed, Jun 14, 3:08 AM · Arcanist, Mercurial, Feature Request

Tue, Jun 13

epriestley closed T12834: Set new hourly rate for our new colleague as Invalid.
Tue, Jun 13, 9:47 AM · Feature Request
banica moved T12834: Set new hourly rate for our new colleague from Needs Information to Backlog on the Feature Request board.
Tue, Jun 13, 8:59 AM · Feature Request
banica moved T12834: Set new hourly rate for our new colleague from Backlog to Future on the Feature Request board.
Tue, Jun 13, 8:58 AM · Feature Request