Bug Report (Needs Information)Bugs
ActivePublic

Properties

Description

A bug report that is not currently able to be reproduced by the upstream. Either based on missing full steps to reproduce the issue or other variables outside of our control. For more information, see https://secure.phabricator.com/book/phabcontrib/article/bug_reports/#unreproducible-problems.

Recent Activity

Fri, May 19

epriestley added a comment to T12722: Auto-resolve with "Fix: T..." commit message should not reopen a closed bug.

Currently, Fixes T123 in a commit message means this:

Fri, May 19, 12:20 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
chad added a comment to T12722: Auto-resolve with "Fix: T..." commit message should not reopen a closed bug.

Basically, you're choosing to use a singular task status to track the various lifetime stages of a bug through multiple branches, which isn't what we intended that field for. It's just as easy to expect QA to want to re-confirm the bug is fixed in master as it is your workflow. I think you should track QA in a custom field.

Fri, May 19, 12:19 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
chad added a comment to T12722: Auto-resolve with "Fix: T..." commit message should not reopen a closed bug.

It still doesn't sound like a bug to me, or maybe more specifically, understand what you expect the upstream to fix.

Fri, May 19, 12:15 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information)

Thu, May 18

zhiyuchen updated the task description for T12722: Auto-resolve with "Fix: T..." commit message should not reopen a closed bug.
Thu, May 18, 9:57 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
zhiyuchen added a comment to T12722: Auto-resolve with "Fix: T..." commit message should not reopen a closed bug.

@avivey If you follow the steps in my description, you should be able to reproduce the problem. I'm also attaching a screenshot which indicates that a maniphest was reopened from "Accepted" to "Resolved" twice because the merge commit msg also contains the original commit msg "... fix T...."

Thu, May 18, 9:56 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
avivey added a comment to T12722: Auto-resolve with "Fix: T..." commit message should not reopen a closed bug.

We need to have enough information to actually see the problem happening, so we can figure out what's wrong, and maybe even test a fix.

Thu, May 18, 7:30 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
zhiyuchen updated subscribers of T12722: Auto-resolve with "Fix: T..." commit message should not reopen a closed bug.

@avivey I updated description to include version info, repeatable and steps to reproduce, is there anything else you guys need?

Thu, May 18, 6:50 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
avivey edited projects for T12722: Auto-resolve with "Fix: T..." commit message should not reopen a closed bug, added: Bug Report (Needs Information); removed Bug Report.
Thu, May 18, 5:09 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)

Mon, May 15

epriestley added a revision to T12710: Project "Profile" and "Subproject" tabs now require members/watchers, but do not load them: D17882: Add required needMembers/needWatchers calls to Project Profile/Subprojects tabs.
Mon, May 15, 1:38 PM · Projects, Bug Report
epriestley added a comment to T12710: Project "Profile" and "Subproject" tabs now require members/watchers, but do not load them.

I'll just ship up the "unbreak" diff, and you can either counter-diff me or figure out something else.

Mon, May 15, 1:36 PM · Projects, Bug Report
epriestley updated subscribers of T12710: Project "Profile" and "Subproject" tabs now require members/watchers, but do not load them.

I think more narrow reproduction instructions are:

Mon, May 15, 1:35 PM · Projects, Bug Report
mrthomasbrix added a comment to T12710: Project "Profile" and "Subproject" tabs now require members/watchers, but do not load them.

Yes on the Almanac project profile.

Mon, May 15, 11:38 AM · Projects, Bug Report
epriestley edited projects for T12710: Project "Profile" and "Subproject" tabs now require members/watchers, but do not load them, added: Bug Report (Needs Information); removed Bug Report.
Mon, May 15, 11:12 AM · Projects, Bug Report

Mon, May 8

cxzzero added a comment to T12687: When submitting an arc diff, svn diff or updating a revision a Parse Exception ocurrs in Windows.

Thanks, let me check that task and I tell you.

Mon, May 8, 7:18 PM · Windows, Bug Report (Needs Information)
avivey added a comment to T12687: When submitting an arc diff, svn diff or updating a revision a Parse Exception ocurrs in Windows.

This might be a variant of T2465. There's some workaround described there that might help.

Mon, May 8, 5:59 PM · Windows, Bug Report (Needs Information)
avivey added a project to T12687: When submitting an arc diff, svn diff or updating a revision a Parse Exception ocurrs in Windows: Windows.
Mon, May 8, 5:56 PM · Windows, Bug Report (Needs Information)
cxzzero added a comment to T12687: When submitting an arc diff, svn diff or updating a revision a Parse Exception ocurrs in Windows.
  • Windows version is Windows 7 with latest updates,
  • PHP version 5.6.13,
  • svn, version 1.9.4 (r1740329), compiled Apr 24 2016, 15:40:35 on x86-microsoft-windows
  • arcanist version mentioned above
Mon, May 8, 5:47 PM · Windows, Bug Report (Needs Information)
chad added a comment to T12687: When submitting an arc diff, svn diff or updating a revision a Parse Exception ocurrs in Windows.

This is a little light on reproduction steps. Can you give us more information such as the version information on Windows, SVN, local arcanist, if you attempted reproduction against a clean Phacility instance or against SVNTest here?

Mon, May 8, 5:38 PM · Windows, Bug Report (Needs Information)
chad edited projects for T12687: When submitting an arc diff, svn diff or updating a revision a Parse Exception ocurrs in Windows, added: Bug Report (Needs Information); removed Bug Report.
Mon, May 8, 5:36 PM · Windows, Bug Report (Needs Information)

Sun, Apr 23

arrowd added a comment to T12521: "(Exception) Expected nonempty 'cmds' specification!" when trying to clone or pull mercurial repository.

After fiddling with some more upgrades, I started to get

Sun, Apr 23, 6:01 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
arrowd added a comment to T12521: "(Exception) Expected nonempty 'cmds' specification!" when trying to clone or pull mercurial repository.

Just faced that problem on my micro hosting. I've updated some software and then started to get the same error as OP when cloning/pulling/pushing mercurial repos. Here is the list of software, that got updated back then: https://paste.kde.org/pqelvuhjf

Sun, Apr 23, 5:32 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)

Apr 13 2017

cspeckmim added a project to T8109: Using 'arc feature' on mercurial repository gave an exception: Bug Report (Needs Information).
Apr 13 2017, 5:48 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information), Mercurial, Arcanist

Apr 11 2017

epriestley added a comment to T12534: Differential still appears in "responsible users" query after resigning as a reviewer.

This is currently expected, although we could consider changing it.

Apr 11 2017, 11:29 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information), Differential
joshuaspence added a comment to T12534: Differential still appears in "responsible users" query after resigning as a reviewer.

When I turn on bucketing, I can't see it actually. Although I do have a lot of diffs, so it could have overheated.

Apr 11 2017, 7:22 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information), Differential
chad added a comment to T12534: Differential still appears in "responsible users" query after resigning as a reviewer.

Where does it go when you turn on bucketing?

Apr 11 2017, 6:59 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information), Differential
chad added a comment to T12534: Differential still appears in "responsible users" query after resigning as a reviewer.

👍🏻 😄

Apr 11 2017, 6:56 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information), Differential
joshuaspence added a comment to T12534: Differential still appears in "responsible users" query after resigning as a reviewer.
Apr 11 2017, 6:39 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information), Differential
chad renamed T12534: Differential still appears in "responsible users" query after resigning as a reviewer from Differential still appears in "responsible users" query after resigning as a reviewier to Differential still appears in "responsible users" query after resigning as a reviewer.
Apr 11 2017, 5:59 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information), Differential

Apr 9 2017

chad edited projects for T12521: "(Exception) Expected nonempty 'cmds' specification!" when trying to clone or pull mercurial repository, added: Bug Report (Needs Information); removed Bug Report.

This still needs complete reproduction steps to be accepted into the upstream. My suggestion is find another VM and load out what you expect the issue is with, and give us those details. Right now it sounds like you're just guessing and that's outside of what we expect when following Contributing Bug Reports. See https://secure.phabricator.com/book/phabcontrib/article/reproduction_steps/ if you need more guidance on providing these steps.

Apr 9 2017, 6:27 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)

Apr 7 2017

epriestley closed T12452: Can't edit task description after upgrading to the latest version as Invalid.

We don't know how to reproduce this and can't move forward.

Apr 7 2017, 12:39 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
epriestley closed T12454: db schema error as Invalid.

We don't know how to reproduce this.

Apr 7 2017, 12:39 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
epriestley closed T12510: Requesting changes as Reviewer and member of blocking Group Reviewer, makes Group Reviewer no longer blocking as Resolved.

That's expected, and not a bug. "Blocking" is currently a top-level status. When a reviewer becomes "Rejecting", they are no longer "Blocking". This doesn't matter in terms of the workflow, because both "Rejecting" and "Blocking" prevent a revision from transitioning to "Accepted".

Apr 7 2017, 11:09 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
claassen added a comment to T12510: Requesting changes as Reviewer and member of blocking Group Reviewer, makes Group Reviewer no longer blocking.

I've repeated this again, taking some screen dumps. This time I did it on a Phacility hosted instance, instead of on our self-hosted instance.

Apr 7 2017, 7:23 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information)

Apr 6 2017

epriestley edited projects for T12510: Requesting changes as Reviewer and member of blocking Group Reviewer, makes Group Reviewer no longer blocking, added: Bug Report (Needs Information); removed Bug Report.
Apr 6 2017, 12:15 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)

Mar 29 2017

eliaspro added a comment to T12454: db schema error.

@dainysunil you need to provide full instructions to reproduce this issue in an untainted environment.

Mar 29 2017, 12:43 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
dainysunil added a comment to T12454: db schema error.

@chad -we tried the upgrade once again .. but the issue is still there

Mar 29 2017, 10:33 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
chad added a comment to T12454: db schema error.

My only guess here is something is corrupt, incomplete, or not upgraded properly. I don't see anything on our side that would lead to this state.

Mar 29 2017, 6:00 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
chad added a comment to T12454: db schema error.

If you believe those are the full, complete steps to reproduce the issue then please take the time and launch a clean test environment and follow the steps and let us know if they are complete.

Mar 29 2017, 5:49 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
dainysunil added a comment to T12454: db schema error.

@chad you need to try upgrade phabricator from branch abff6dc8a9b4e081d74beaf8f062223cb5308ec3 to reproduce the issue. Can you consider this as step to reproduce the error.

Mar 29 2017, 5:46 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
chad added a comment to T12454: db schema error.

We don't accept bug reports without reproduction steps.

Mar 29 2017, 5:43 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information)
dainysunil added a comment to T12454: db schema error.

Please find the image with upgrade branch. While upgrading the phabricator from this branch we found this error. Please check this upgrade to reproduce the error.

Mar 29 2017, 5:39 AM · Bug Report (Needs Information)

Mar 28 2017

epriestley edited projects for T12454: db schema error, added: Bug Report (Needs Information); removed Bug Report.

If you believe you've found a bug in Phabricator, we need all the information discussed in Contributing Bug Reports to move forward. Specifically:

Mar 28 2017, 12:55 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)

Mar 27 2017

epriestley edited projects for T12452: Can't edit task description after upgrading to the latest version, added: Bug Report (Needs Information); removed Bug Report.

We need reproduction steps to move forward. See Providing Reproduction Steps.

Mar 27 2017, 3:11 PM · Bug Report (Needs Information)

Mar 22 2017

cspeckmim updated the task description for T12369: Users sometimes prompted to "Edit Locked Task" when attempting to create a new task.
Mar 22 2017, 3:45 AM · Bug Report, EditEngine
cspeckmim updated the task description for T12369: Users sometimes prompted to "Edit Locked Task" when attempting to create a new task.
Mar 22 2017, 3:30 AM · Bug Report, EditEngine
cspeckmim updated the task description for T12369: Users sometimes prompted to "Edit Locked Task" when attempting to create a new task.
Mar 22 2017, 3:25 AM · Bug Report, EditEngine
cspeckmim updated the task description for T12369: Users sometimes prompted to "Edit Locked Task" when attempting to create a new task.
Mar 22 2017, 3:24 AM · Bug Report, EditEngine
cspeckmim renamed T12369: Users sometimes prompted to "Edit Locked Task" when attempting to create a new task from Locked task on create new one to Users sometimes prompted to "Edit Locked Task" when attempting to create a new task.
Mar 22 2017, 3:23 AM · Bug Report, EditEngine
cspeckmim added a comment to T12369: Users sometimes prompted to "Edit Locked Task" when attempting to create a new task.

Thanks @chad for the help and motivation~

Mar 22 2017, 3:18 AM · Bug Report, EditEngine
chad added a comment to T12369: Users sometimes prompted to "Edit Locked Task" when attempting to create a new task.

nyancat

Mar 22 2017, 3:17 AM · Bug Report, EditEngine