Hello.
Sorry for bothering but i would like to share my impression and suggestion.
I do really like this quick edit task button in maniphest tasks list view {F101775}
But unfortunately there is no way to add any comments from that quick view. I'm free to do anything (that can be done with task) except post a comment.
Possibly I'm missing something but if not i would suggest to add such functionality to quick edit view.
| Status | Assigned | Task | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Open | None | T4316 Allow a comment to be added on the Maniphest edit interface | ||
| Resolved | epriestley | T9132 Build an ApplicationEditor abstraction | ||
| Resolved | epriestley | T5752 Navigation menus should work correctly on mobile by default | ||
| Resolved | chad | T8099 Mid-2015 Phabricator Redesign | ||
| Resolved | chad | T8338 Unable to re-arrange Maniphest tasks into 1st row when dragging (redesign branch) | ||
| Resolved | chad | T8339 Allow setting of icons in maniphest.status | ||
| Resolved | chad | T8341 Identify anywhere we didn't use icons where barColor was used | ||
| Resolved | chad | T8342 Design a new PHUIPagerView, allow setting to objects | ||
| Resolved | chad | T8549 Feedback on 2015 Redesign | ||
| Open | None | T9690 Remove calls to methods deprecated by newPage() | ||
| Resolved | None | T9871 Some PHUI form controls do not have identifiable "disabled" states | ||
| Duplicate | None | T9913 ApplicationEditor stacked comment actions can't be removed on mobile |
Specifically, you want to add a comment in addition to taking some other action, not just post a comment, right?
Yap that would be full task handling process inside of that view. If i would like just to add some comments i would just live all other fields untouchable.
yeah, I've often canceled my changes in the Edit page only to make the same changes using the Comment Action thingie in the View page. Simply because I want to comment my changes and I want the comment to be in the same row block as the changes, not a separate row block.
The comment should be merged into the same row if you perform an edit and then leave a comment, as long as it takes you less than 2-3 minutes to write your comment and no intervening activity takes place.
T9132 gives us more options for accommodating this this without needing to put comment boxes on every edit form.
Whilst it does get merged in the web UI, at the risk of picking over old wounds, it causes two separate mails to get sent out, e.g. 'Raised Priority' followed shortly by 'Commented'; doing it as a single transaction through the task detail view only generates a single 'Triaged' email for the same edit.