In T1279#42118, @epriestley wrote:

• Ad-Hoc Blocking Reviewers: There's no way to add blocking reviewers from Differential or the CLI (T731). Despite some user interest, I still have a hard time understanding the need for voluntarily adding blocking reviewers.

@epriestley I'll keep an eye on blueprints and the merge configurability. Thank you. Phabricator is awesome/and getting awesomer.

All the policy, merge strategy, etc., stuff is hard-coded to the easiest set of reasonable defaults. Some of these defaults may not be suitable for many installs (e.g., always rebase, always merge to master, require edit capability for imported repositories in order to perform merges). I expect to expand these shortly, I just don't want to focus on making things more flexible until they actually work.

Getting a ruleset for N of M reviewers would be enormously helpful, if while you are doing this you see a good way to add a time criteria that would help us out. Our current ruleset is roughly ( (90% of reviewers approve) AND (no one requested changes) ) OR ( (it has been 8 business hours) AND (at lease 2 reviewers approve) ) We anticipate in the future we may need to prove this rule is being followed so we are very interested in this feature.

We would really appreciate this!

Thanks @qgil

We want to migrate to phabricator from trac, but to get buy-in we need to migrate trac tickets and their custom fields to Maniphest tickets. As I understand we can either wait on this ticket, or delve into the code and try to resolve this. Is there any other option?

We also want this!

Same problem here.