| epriestley | |
| Oct 31 2019, 5:05 PM |
| F7000083: image.png | |
| Nov 4 2019, 7:57 PM |
| F6989724: Screen Shot 2019-10-31 at 10.01.04 AM.png | |
| Oct 31 2019, 5:05 PM |
See PHI1508. Currently, commits and revisions on tasks are rendered in a slightly-enriched list view:
It might be nice to render these in a richer tabular format, somewhat similar to the task graph.
(The request in PHI1508 is narrowly about including repository information, specifically, but I suspect this UI can be broadly improved.)
Layout looks very neat but a strange too with that big space gap between the icon on each row and the actual text in this case:
The empty space means "this is a normal commit with no special audit state", and the column collapses if no commits have issues (see this task for an example). That seems fairly reasonable to me?
I could put a grey "(No Audit Concerns)" in every row, but that doesn't seem very useful.
I could just use an icon (instead of a full tag with a text label) but I generally don't like that UI pattern very much and would like to move away from unlabeled / hover-to-understand icons in the UI where there isn't a very strong reason for an interface to work like that.
I could put a grey "(No Audit Concerns)" tag in every row, then remove them all if no row has a different status, I suppose.
Does this still strike you as weird after you've had some time to get used to it?
It wasn't a major UI issue to start with and yes, you get used to it. I would ignore.
Sounds good. It felt slightly odd to me at first, too, but I think I also got used to it.
I think Diffusion is going to get a similar treatment at some point, so maybe I'll revisit the UI then if there's some opportunity to adjust this in order to make the UIs more consistent or whatever.