Page MenuHomePhabricator
Create Task
Maniphest T13309

Git protocol proxy can not parse protocol frames if repository on disk is a shallow clone
Closed, ResolvedPublic
Actions

Description

See https://discourse.phabricator-community.org/t/how-to-have-a-shallow-git-mirror/2805/.

If you manually put a shallow clone in place on disk, git fetch fails when proxied:

# Cleared to fetch on cluster host "local.phacility.net".
Exception: Unexpected "git upload-pack" protocol frame: expected "<hash> <name>\n", got "shallow 0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180
".
fatal: Could not read from remote repository.

There is no legitimate way to get a shallow clone on disk and hosting shallow clones is not supported, but we should still parse the frames.

Revisions and Commits

Restricted Differential RevisionRestricted Diffusion Commit

Event Timeline

epriestley triaged this task as Wishlist priority.Jun 13 2019, 10:42 PM
epriestley created this task.
Herald added a subscriber: amckinley. · View Herald TranscriptJun 13 2019, 10:42 PM
epriestley added a comment.Jun 13 2019, 10:42 PM

To reproduce this, you can:

$ cd /var/repo
$ mv 123 123-full-repository
$ git clone --depth 1 file:///var/repo/123-full-repository 123

Then git clone <uri> the repository.

epriestley added a comment.Jun 13 2019, 10:46 PM

Here's what goes over the wire:

< Write [1,432 bytes]
<  30313032 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20484541  01020ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 HEA
<  44006d75 6c74695f 61636b20 7468696e 2d706163 6b207369 64652d62 616e6420 73696465 2d62616e 642d3634 6b206f66  D.multi_ack thin-pack side-band side-band-64k of
<  732d6465 6c746120 7368616c 6c6f7720 64656570 656e2d73 696e6365 20646565 70656e2d 6e6f7420 64656570 656e2d72  s-delta shallow deepen-since deepen-not deepen-r
<  656c6174 69766520 6e6f2d70 726f6772 65737320 696e636c 7564652d 74616720 6d756c74 695f6163 6b5f6465 7461696c  elative no-progress include-tag multi_ack_detail
<  65642073 796d7265 663d4845 41443a72 6566732f 68656164 732f6d61 73746572 20616765 6e743d67 69742f32 2e32302e  ed symref=HEAD:refs/heads/master agent=git/2.20.
<  312e2841 70706c65 2e476974 2d313137 290a                                                                     1.(Apple.Git-117).
<  30303366 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  003f0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f6865 6164732f 6d617374 65720a                                                                            s/heads/master.
<  30303436 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  00460ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7265 6d6f7465 732f6f72 6967696e 2f484541 440a                                                            s/remotes/origin/HEAD.
<  30303438 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  00480ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7265 6d6f7465 732f6f72 6967696e 2f6d6173 7465720a                                                        s/remotes/origin/master.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3137360a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/176.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3137370a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/177.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3138330a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/183.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3138340a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/184.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3138350a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/185.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3138360a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/186.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3138370a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/187.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3138390a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/189.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3139310a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/191.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3139330a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/193.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3139350a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/195.
<  30303463 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366 65313830 20726566  004c0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cfe180 ref
<  732f7461 67732f70 68616272 69636174 6f722f62 6173652f 3139380a                                               s/tags/phabricator/base/198.
<  30303335 7368616c 6c6f7720 30636531 37323262 31363837 63323630 62393233 65306163 62326563 63333737 32316366  0035shallow 0ce1722b1687c260b923e0acb2ecc37721cf
<  65313830 0a                                                                                                  e180.
<  30303030                                                                                                     0000
epriestley added a comment.EditedJun 13 2019, 11:28 PM

The shallow <hash> frames can not advertise capabilities.

You can create a repository with only "shallow" frames by cloning a repository with --depth, then deleting all the refs. In this case, the wire will include only "shallow" frames with no capabilities advertisement:

< Write [57 bytes]
<  30303335 7368616c 6c6f7720 64623764 63393933 64346662 30646439 61366233 37653332 65376263 37653138 63373132  0035shallow db7dc993d4fb0dd9a6b37e32e7bc7e18c712
<  32313035 0a                                                                                                  2105.
<  30303030                                                                                                     0000
epriestley added a revision: Restricted Differential Revision.Jun 13 2019, 11:31 PM
epriestley closed this task as Resolved by committing Restricted Diffusion Commit.Jun 18 2019, 10:15 PM
epriestley claimed this task.
epriestley added a commit: Restricted Diffusion Commit.
Phabricator · Built by Phacility