| Current Revision |
|---|
Basic idea is to rely on color to indicate state and re-use icons for simplicity. From left to right:
The main idea is everyone starts grey, then if they comment or start a draft, turn blue. Tooltips on the review could give state and time for additional context.
These look good, but they seem very heavy/important visually -- maybe out of line with their actual importance?
I think this is a overly heavy example, not likely IRL. But in general I agree. I would probably re-design the top of differential to go along with something like this, since it could use a little more structure. I can also try a pass with just colored icons, but that didn't feel good in my first pass.
I'd probably also like to use this element in Diffusion to show auditors -- the old table we had was already huge, and now we have an objectlist view which is xbox-sized. This thing:
{F50223}
...is 90% redundant and should really just be:
| An Icon? | ...with this tooltip? | tag or link | Light grey text or maybe tooltip |
|---|---|---|---|
| √ | Accepted | btrahan | Requested by Author |
| ? | Audit Requested | HidupBangsaku | Herald Rule "example" |
| ? | Audit Requested | Fakhra.Aftab | Herald Rule "whatever" |
| ! | Concern Raised | #cowboy | Owners Package "Everything" |
...and get a treatment identical to Reviewers in Differential.