This would be especially useful in conjunction with T6874

The main concern here is that type of UI is worse for as many people as it is better for. Our overall intention with Phabricator, specifically, is that it is a product built for improving code quality. For that, our expectations are that comments are well formed and thought out, not short quick snips. We also believe in information density, so the comments are a bit of a "table of contents" and that the discussion should occur directly on the code.

That said there are mocks floating around that add an additional dialog display (code + comments) that could be something you'd be interested in, but I don't see something like that being built for some time.

Here’s an example. There are 2 conversations and some one-offs going on here, but trying to follow what is being discussed is already fairly difficult. This is a mild example - it fit on one screen.

Our general recommendation is for people who unhappy with various aspects of Phabricator is that they should fork the project to meet their company's needs. Differential improvements / overhauls aren't on the current roadmap and suggestions are unlikely to thoughtfully addressed for years. We're simply too small (3 people) for spend as much time as the community sometimes wants debating fine details.

In T6873#90197, @anton.vladimirov wrote:

Here’s an example. There are 2 conversations and some one-offs going on here, but trying to follow what is being discussed is already fairly difficult. This is a mild example - it fit on one screen.

Doh! That was meant for T6876

That’s totally understandable. I was under the impression that you discourage local forks though. Seeing that all of my requests seem to converge onto T1460, if I wanted to help out with that how would I go about it?