Page MenuHomePhabricator

Delist or heavily caveat "arc-jira" and "phabricator-jira" extensions
Closed, ResolvedPublic


There are two projects on the Facebook GitHub which look like they're supported Phabricator extensions, but are not:

I believe these were written by a Facebook intern about two years ago for Hive. There's a bunch of discussion in T1206. These projects are very old, unsupported, and do not represent modern approaches to JIRA integration.

Because it's not clear that these projects aren't under the Phabricator umbrella, users will occasionally try to install them (see for the most recent example). These projects are almost certainly unsuitable for use anywhere except

I think it would be helpful for users on the balance to have these projects removed, or at least marked prominently as not supported and generally unlikely to be useful.

(Hive has also moved away from; although I'm not certain what the whole story is there.)

We can't practically take these projects over, because change will break and we don't have anyone who can help with making sure that goes smoothly (see D2450 for the last attempt). The approaches used by these projects (primarily, emailing stuff to JIRA) also don't have a future in modern integration (modern Phabricator has proper API-based integration with JIRA).

Event Timeline

epriestley assigned this task to jamesgpearce.
epriestley raised the priority of this task from to Wishlist.
epriestley updated the task description. (Show Details)
epriestley added a project: GitHub.
epriestley added subscribers: epriestley, btrahan, chad and 2 others.

We can look at updating them. Thanks for the heads up.

I'm not sure these extensions really do anything the upstream doesn't anymore, except "work with the specific workflow used on". See T3687. Particularly, here are some screenshots of JIRA integration in the modern upstream with no extensions:

Screen_Shot_2013-09-07_at_10.13.28_AM.png (158×1 px, 18 KB)

Screen_Shot_2013-09-03_at_2.49.20_PM.png (631×905 px, 73 KB)

Screen_Shot_2013-09-03_at_2.49.32_PM.png (1×943 px, 197 KB)

Screen_Shot_2014-01-29_at_9.08.00_AM.png (1×1 px, 289 KB)

Screen_Shot_2014-01-29_at_9.08.40_AM.png (192×619 px, 20 KB)

Some more confusion from a user in IRC today:

<robk>: hey epriestley_, question, how exactly is : used w/ jira

Could you add any details on what the recommended 'current approach' might be for JIRA integration?