Page MenuHomePhabricator

Commandeered revisions do not show original author as "Authored By"
Closed, WontfixPublic

Description

Reproduction steps:

  • As user A, create a revision.
  • As user B, commandeer the revision.

Expected result:

  • The revision says "Authored by user A on (date)"

Actual result

  • The revision says "Authored by user B on (date)"

Version: current stable

Event Timeline

epriestley claimed this task.
epriestley added a subscriber: epriestley.

Although this wording is a little unclear, commandeering makes you the author. A more precise wording would be something like "The current author for this revision is X. It was created on Y." but that's clunky and only smooths out this particular case.

Normally, commandeering should be rare, and the sequence of events is evident from the edit timeline. We haven't seen other users encounter confusion with this.

If you have a use case where commandeering is common or this is particularly confusing or unclear, please file a feature request describing it instead (see Contributing Feature Requests). If you're frequently commandeering, we might prefer to find a workflow which does not require commandeering.