After using these, I've literally clicked every single one of these I've hit. I never remember what they said and always want to read them.

:(

Maybe we should add a preference?

• Show Full
• Show Collapsed (Default)
• Hide

I hate adding preferences, but this feature was like 10x better for me before the collapse change.

I can try to get summarizing kind of working before we go that far, I just think it's going to be junk in a bunch of cases. Not sure if that will be 2% of cases or 35%.

I'd remove the collapse and just make a JS toggle / pref. show old / hide old. I don't mind preferences when I feel people are going to be opinionated on both sides and we want everyone to feel productive.

Probably still keep some icon indication ghost comments exist though even if you have them off?

That seems reasonable, but might be tricky to implement.

What can I do here for next steps then?

• Remove 'minimal UI'
• Add keyboard shortcut to toggle ghost on and off
• Add sticky preference (or settings preference?)
• Add UI hint that old comments exist

I can do some of these, just didn't know if you were also working on them.

Let me try to do summaries first and see how bad that actually is, I really hate preferences.

If that route, probably also open them all with one click instead of individual. Like, you either want to read it all or just have a small summary.

This isn't really even close in a bunch of cases:

Yeah I faked it by just pulling up the text from the first p tag, and hiding everything else.