Change Details

NOTE: This task is currently incomplete, more details will be available shortly. Summary ======= Phabricator uses the `hg` command line binary to serve some requests for information about Mercurial repositories. The `hg` binary treats the flags `--config=...` and `--debugger` specially, and evaluates them as flags in //any// position. Attackers could exploit this by accessing certain branches or files with names like `--config=...` or `--debugger` to execute code remotely. You are vulnerable if: - The Phabricator server has `hg` installed. - An attacker can browse any Mercurial repository in Diffusion. The mitigation (available in 2017 Week 45) refuses to execute any `hg` command where any argument begins with `--config` or `--debugger`. Mercurial anticipates providing a "hardened" mode in a future release with stricter argument parsing rules. Mercurial Behavior ============== Mercurial parses the `--config` and `--debugger` flags in an unusual, nonstandard way: it processes them before processing other flags and arguments, including flags which take arguments and the `--` "end of flags" marker. For example, this command: ``` $ hg log -- --debugger ``` ...invokes the debugger. Likewise, this: ``` $ hg log --branch --debugger ``` ...means "invoke the debugger", not "log the branch named `--debugger`". Note that `--debugger` is a valid Mercurial branch name, but to create it you must do this: ``` $ hg branch --debugger --debugger ``` Then enter `c` to convince the debugger to continue execution. The `--debugger` flag is dangerous (remote code execution) if users control `stdin`. See CVE-2017-9462 for an earlier attack using this flag. See also D18611 and followup in D18616. The `--config` flag is also dangerous and can also enable remote code execution with, e.g., `--config=hooks.pre-log=whoami` in a `log` command. Broadly, the behavior of Mercurial is this: (WARNING) The argument `--debugger`, and any argument beginning with `--config`, are unsafe to pass to Mercurial as part of //any// command, in //any// position, even after a `--` "end of flags" marker. Callers must filter arguments and reject any such argument before passing it to `hg`. Generally, the `hg` binary can not interact normally with files named `--debugger`, branches named `--debugger`, bookmarks named `--debugger`, search for the pattern `--debugger` using `grep`, etc., even though this is a valid file name, a valid branch name, a valid bookmark name, a valid pattern, and so on. Likewise for `--config`. See also CVE-2017-1000116, although this is not as closely related as the `--debugger` vulnerability. Phabricator Behavior ================ Phabricator incorrectly assumed that Mercurial used standard behavior for all flags, and executed some commands like these: ``` hg log --branch <branch_name> --rev <revset> ``` An attacker could browse a branch named something like `--config=execute=evil` (which is a valid Mercurial branch name) in the web UI, and cause Phabricator to execute an `hg` command with `--branch '--config=...'`. Normally, binaries Via HackerOne. See also <https://hackerone.com/reports/288704>.

Summary ======= Phabricator uses the `hg` command line binary to serve some requests for information about Mercurial repositories. The `hg` binary treats the flags `--config=...` and `--debugger` specially, and evaluates them as flags in //any// position. Attackers could exploit this by accessing certain branches or files with names like `--config=...` or `--debugger` to execute code remotely. You are vulnerable if: - The Phabricator server has `hg` installed. - An attacker can browse any Mercurial repository in Diffusion. The mitigation (available in 2017 Week 45) refuses to execute any `hg` command where any argument begins with `--config` or `--debugger`. Mercurial anticipates providing a "hardened" mode in a future release with stricter argument parsing rules. This issue was reported to us via HackerOne. See <https://hackerone.com/reports/288704> (this may not yet be public, but should become public once the researcher agrees to disclosure). Mercurial Behavior ============== Mercurial parses the special `--config` and `--debugger` flags in an unusual way: it processes them before processing other flags and arguments, including flags which take arguments and the `--` "end of flags" marker. For example, this command: ``` $ hg log -- --debugger ``` ...invokes the debugger. Likewise, this: ``` $ hg log --branch --debugger ``` ...means "invoke the debugger", not "log the branch named `--debugger`". Note that `--debugger` is a valid Mercurial branch name, but to create it you must do this: ``` $ hg branch --debugger --debugger ``` Then enter `c` to convince the debugger to continue execution. The `--debugger` flag is dangerous (remote code execution) if users control `stdin`. See CVE-2017-9462 for an earlier attack using this flag. See also D18611 and followup in D18616. The `--config` flag is also dangerous and can also enable remote code execution with, e.g., `--config=hooks.pre-log=whoami` in a `log` command. Broadly, the behavior of Mercurial is this: (WARNING) The argument `--debugger`, and any argument beginning with `--config`, are unsafe to pass to Mercurial as part of //any// command, in //any// position, even after a `--` "end of flags" marker. Callers must filter arguments and reject any such argument before passing it to `hg`. Generally, the `hg` binary can not interact normally with files named `--debugger`, branches named `--debugger`, bookmarks named `--debugger`, search for the pattern `--debugger` using `grep`, etc., even though this is a valid file name, a valid branch name, a valid bookmark name, a valid pattern, and so on. Likewise for `--config`. See also CVE-2017-1000116, although this is not as closely related as the `--debugger` vulnerability. Phabricator Behavior ================ Phabricator incorrectly assumed that Mercurial used standard behavior for all flags, and executed some commands like this: ``` hg log --branch <branch_name> --rev <revset> ``` An attacker could browse a branch named something like `--config=execute=evil` (which is a valid Mercurial branch name) in the web UI, and cause Phabricator to execute an `hg` command with `--branch '--config=...'`. Normally, binaries parse the second argument as a parameter for the `--branch` argument, not a separate flag, but Mercurial treats `--config` and `--debugger` specially and parses them as flags in any position. Since there is no way to escape these flags, we now filter them and refuse to execute commands with any `--config` or `--debugger` argument.

NOTE: This task is currently incomplete, more details will be available shortly. Summary ======= Phabricator uses the `hg` command line binary to serve some requests for information about Mercurial repositories. The `hg` binary treats the flags `--config=...` and `--debugger` specially, and evaluates them as flags in //any// position. Attackers could exploit this by accessing certain branches or files with names like `--config=...` or `--debugger` to execute code remotely. You are vulnerable if: - The Phabricator server has `hg` installed. - An attacker can browse any Mercurial repository in Diffusion. The mitigation (available in 2017 Week 45) refuses to execute any `hg` command where any argument begins with `--config` or `--debugger`. Mercurial anticipates providing a "hardened" mode in a future release with stricter argument parsing rules. This issue was reported to us via HackerOne. See <https://hackerone.com/reports/288704> (this may not yet be public, but should become public once the researcher agrees to disclosure). Mercurial Behavior ============== Mercurial parses the special `--config` and `--debugger` flags in an unusual, nonstandard way: it processes them before processing other flags and arguments, including flags which take arguments and the `--` "end of flags" marker. For example, this command: ``` $ hg log -- --debugger ``` ...invokes the debugger. Likewise, this: ``` $ hg log --branch --debugger ``` ...means "invoke the debugger", not "log the branch named `--debugger`". Note that `--debugger` is a valid Mercurial branch name, but to create it you must do this: ``` $ hg branch --debugger --debugger ``` Then enter `c` to convince the debugger to continue execution. The `--debugger` flag is dangerous (remote code execution) if users control `stdin`. See CVE-2017-9462 for an earlier attack using this flag. See also D18611 and followup in D18616. The `--config` flag is also dangerous and can also enable remote code execution with, e.g., `--config=hooks.pre-log=whoami` in a `log` command. Broadly, the behavior of Mercurial is this: (WARNING) The argument `--debugger`, and any argument beginning with `--config`, are unsafe to pass to Mercurial as part of //any// command, in //any// position, even after a `--` "end of flags" marker. Callers must filter arguments and reject any such argument before passing it to `hg`. Generally, the `hg` binary can not interact normally with files named `--debugger`, branches named `--debugger`, bookmarks named `--debugger`, search for the pattern `--debugger` using `grep`, etc., even though this is a valid file name, a valid branch name, a valid bookmark name, a valid pattern, and so on. Likewise for `--config`. See also CVE-2017-1000116, although this is not as closely related as the `--debugger` vulnerability. Phabricator Behavior ================ Phabricator incorrectly assumed that Mercurial used standard behavior for all flags, and executed some commands like these:this: ``` hg log --branch <branch_name> --rev <revset> ``` An attacker could browse a branch named something like `--config=execute=evil` (which is a valid Mercurial branch name) in the web UI, and cause Phabricator to execute an `hg` command with `--branch '--config=...'`. Normally, binaries Via HackerOne.parse the second argument as a parameter for the `--branch` argument, not a separate flag, See also <https://hackerone.com/reports/288704>. but Mercurial treats `--config` and `--debugger` specially and parses them as flags in any position. Since there is no way to escape these flags, we now filter them and refuse to execute commands with any `--config` or `--debugger` argument.